Well done but Oddly Written

Any additional comments?

If you have an interest in Spielberg there are some gems to be gleaned. The writing style is a bit stilted which might make the audio an acquired taste. The book is narrated by Johnny Heller, who does a great job of making the text accessible. Noticed another review here mentioning a problem with "her" on the audio ??? There is a few minute intro by narrator Perrin which is Ms. Haskell's intro, which is fine, although again, the text is not fluid, but the entire book is read only by Heller. Again, I think it's an acquired taste.

2 people found this helpful

Haskell hates Spielberg

This verbose author writes about a director she clearly resents. She's so in love with her own voice as she makes wild & condescending assumptions about a man she has never met.
The vocal performance is good!

1 person found this helpful

Okay bio but should’ve researched author

Narrators did a great job. I was turned off by Haskell’s wining at the beginning of the bio and her hyper-critical tone throughout the reading.

Narrator is great. A lot of book is psychoanalysis

What did you like best about Steven Spielberg? What did you like least?

The best thing about the book is narrator Johnny Heller. His voice is reminiscent of Hector Elizondo and great to listen to.

As for the book's content: From the early years of Spielberg's grandparents, parents, and Spielberg himself, a lot of the book is an attempt at psychoanalysis of Spielberg's work and how his childhood has repeatedly put characters that are missing fathers and other factors.

Having a Bachelors in Psychology, I felt this approach was very heavy, droll, and while maybe a bit of interest, overall too pervasive. I would rather have learned actual stories about the making of his films, how he chooses his projects, etc than an attempt to frame his work from a "his childhood caused this to be a plot point" approach.

All in all, not a very enjoyable book.

Would you be willing to try another book from Molly Haskell? Why or why not?

If all of her books are written from a psychoanalytic standpoint, probably not. I like biographies and memoirs that educate me about stories from the making of the film.

Evaluating how someone's father leaving at an early age created a repetitive theme of fatherless children in a director's films may be educational to a point, but it should be at most a 15 minute evaluation where the films that have that theme are discussed. Not hours.

Basically, his father leaving, being Jewish, and the Holocaust have shaped everything in this book. If that sounds simplistic, it may be a reaction to the book being repetitive to the point of trying to beat the message into you.

Which scene was your favorite?

Discussions regarding his rise, his setting up of everything from films to his offices, actual things that happened rather than opinions.

Did Steven Spielberg inspire you to do anything?

Keep an eye out for books narrated by Johnny Heller!!!

Any additional comments?

I believe the book was written either as a thesis/school project (hence the heavy analysis) or by someone who has a background in Psychology and wanted to apply their education/views on to Spielberg's work. For that purpose, this book would be great.

But beyond watching E.T., Schindler's List, etc and holding them up against Spielberg's life history for analysis, the book lacks a lot of inside anecdotes regarding the actual making of Spielberg's films that one typically finds when reading a biography of a person's work that goes year by year, film by film.

Her voice is like a robots voice. I can go on listen to it! Bummer

Her voice is like a robots voice. I can go on listen to it! Bummer