Entertained and Informed across Continents

Great narration, brilliant content as always. Covers every continent and the relevant geopolitics in an entertaining way.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

So interesting

Loved this book, full of interesting facts and historical information. The African and Middle Eastern chapters especially added so much context to where the world is now. I do wish audiobooks could have illustrations.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good book, with some interesting history

really liked this one, however it's nothing compared to prisoners of geography another tim Marshall book. if enjoyed this one give that one ago.

the book is well thought out and explains some fascinating history behind some of the key flags in the world, however most will recognize that certain flags have more meaning to certain groups already.

that being said you are bound to find something you did not know about certain cultures and flags, which will help your understanding of geo politics.

the book is well read and laid out, would definitely recommend to anyone.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good content, dodgy accents!

The content is great, however I struggled with the narrator's accents, Russian and Portuguese stand out as particularly bad. The accents aren't necessary.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Bad narration

I really like Tim Marshall but when I heard the narrator i cringed as I've already experienced 20+ hours in a Daniel Todman book so I knew what was coming. It's a shame the narrator indulges in accents and emphasis where none are needed.
Sadly I have another 40+ hours in another Dan Todman book to look forward to.....

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Fantastic book, so-so narration

Another fascinating book by Tim Marshall,only let down by the narrator’s poor attempts at various accents. If he just read it normally it would have been fine as he has a good narration voice generally but his distractingly bad accents undermine his overall performance.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good content, average narration

Great variety in content but the fake accents are a real turnoff and pretty hard to listen to

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Very interesting

Some slightly dubious accents from the narrator. They were not necessary and sometimes distracted from the dialogue

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

10 people found this helpful

Ok. But just ok.

I tend to find Marshall a bit smug.

His work is decent entry-level, blanket-statement stuff. A good all-round surface level skim over the links between flags, "worship" in some senses, propaganda and politics. But personally it didn't tell me anything I didn't already know. (Smug did you say?!)

I hoped for an (at least) fairly deep dive on the psychology between flags and being willing to die for one's country. How pieces of cloth can inspire feelings of tremendous patriotism and nationalism and self sacrifice. No such luck...

Indeed areas of "Worth dying for" struck me as being somewhat dense or unthinking of Marshall. He seems to want to brush over the long lasting effects of colonialism/imperialism and it's symbology; basically suggesting we need to forget the horrors of empire and look upon the union flag in the spirit of that which it was intended...

For instance, his assertion that anyone seeing issues with the Union Jack is a "self hating westerner" is exactly the opposite of my life experience thus far. I'd actually put it to Tim that anyone fighting (or whom have fought) for our language, culture & our lands against gentrification (etc.) are the exact opposite of self hating.

He also echoes the thoughts of many a right-wing YouTuber here by asking that very popular question. Which makes me wonder whether this book was aimed at 6th formers or the market surrounding that age bracket.

Why is it the Nazis are seen as more evil than the Stalin's USSR & Mao's China? Well, this is a huge question and demands a huge answer, that I'm nowhere near qualified to give. And I think we can safely say the same for Marshall here. He simply wishes to compare death tolls and be done with it; not taking into consideration historical context etc. That's fine as an at-a-glance introduction to these subjects but is typical of shallow, centrist thinking, and it isn't helpful in the long run. Also... Perhaps Marshall could adopt his approach to the union jack to leftist politics? You know, forget the horror of dictatorship and look forward to a new era of socialism!?! (Never that simple, is it Tim? And always odd when something so ridiculous is spun back on oneself.)

Another point on the Nazis worth noting is that something called the Nuremberg laws were most definitely inspired by Jim Crow laws and had huge support in American from very early on. Now, Marshall admits the latter; mentioning the American German Bund. But then proclaims that anyone suggesting a link between American values and Nazism doesn't know their history. I'd argue the opposite. I'd argue that anyone drawing links between certain periods in American history & Hitler's vision for Nazism has a point. BUT, as Marshall suggests, if by drawing swastikas instead of stars on 'old glory' you think you're contributing anything of value to the conversation you're sorely wrong.

On Islam Marshall is fair and reasonable. He insists on more than one occasion that the Wahhabism pushed by the Saudis & ISIS is not the same as regular old Islam. This is a very important point that I cannot drive home enough.

Over all I found the style of writing paired with the narration to be enjoyable. Tim has a flair for the colourful & fun and perhaps it was indeed the narration that made his words seem smugger than they would have had I have read this as opposed to listening to it.

About the narration... I've noticed others claiming that Ric Jerom's narration put them to sleep or grated on them. I must admit I had no real issue with it. In fact i'd say it was the best bit of this production, smug or otherwise.

The book, on the whole was a disappointment. I'm not sure whether I'll now delve into his other work after listening to this. If Tim's work is all surface level blanket statement stuff, I'll probably not.

I'm not saying this is an awful book, it's just not for me. Sorry.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

Great Listen

I never knew there was so much about a flag. A must for anybody who wants education a clear and concise book it touched the spot for me.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!