Crisp but complex, with an unusual narrative style

You most likely know how the story ends before you listen to the first chapter, but until the last hour you do not know why it ended that way. That mystery drives the listener to stay tuned. Gorenberg spins a series of threads that wind through time (1940-42) and place (North Africa). He does not always share why he needs to include certain threads, and there is a McGuffin or two in some of them. But that is part of the fun. The notion that something previously unknown - occurring within the immature American army - might have caused both Britain's worst defeat (Tobruk 1942) and greatest victory (El Alamein, months later), and ultimately saved the Middle East from Europe's fate, is by itself enough reason to add this book to your library. It does not disappoint.

1 person found this helpful

Enigma, espionage and battlefields

This book give a good account of code breaking and espionage during ww2 in North Africa, the British mandate of Palestine and how this changed the face of ww2.

Superbly researched & magnificently told.

Real-life WW2 spy thriller set in the crosshairs of Britain’s waning rule in Egypt and the country’s competing nationalists. Marvelously told, it will keep you on your toes while steeping you in North African geography, Rommel’s escapades, and the more-than-brilliant achievements of Britain’s codebreakers. One flaw: no recognition given to American Elizabeth Friedman, whose deciphering skills were on par with those of her much-referenced husband William.

Interesting history: mediocre narration.

The narrator speaks with a hollow, hoarse voice and slopppily pronounces some words. For this reason alone I do not recommend this otherwise important book.

Interesting but complicated book

Fascinating to learn about all the behind the scenes going on’s of the Middle Eastern war. However, as others have said it was hard to keep track of who was who so having a hard copy of the book would have made this easier to follow. The author did jump around the timeline quite a bit which also made it harder to follow. But, on the whole I still enjoyed the story. It does make you feel sorry for all those amazing code breakers who were never recognized publicly for their war winning work. Would definitely recommend a hard copy rather than audio though. The reader’s voice is not the nicest to listen to, and he mispronounced a number of words.

a new angle on a story I thought I Knew

loved the narration and the content both
lots of new detail and a new perspective

Super Story

Great book! Well written and performed. Learned a great deal about an important part of world history.

Riveting

Mr. Berman's cadence and intriguing voice adds volumes to this circuitous account of the secretive sides of WWII. Thank you.

Excellent

A well written and informative story of war, secrets and how they played out in Africa and the Middle East during WWII.

Riveting, reads like a well written spy novel

From the opening scene of impending doom in Cairo, through the twists and turns of the dessert campaigns of World War Two and the parallel spy war that shaped the outcome, this historical tour-de-force reads like a novel. I couldn’t put it down.