Great Course but need written text

Any additional comments?

I am a big fan of Professor Bartlett. History could be full of wars, names and dates which tend to be pretty boring, but Bartlett has managed to keep audience interested by personalizing the historical figures, their background, character, journey in the way that you and I can related. He also provided various aspects of the Italian culture that we still can see today when we visit the country. In so doing, ancient history becomes highly relevant to today’s Italy and Italians, and how we appreciate them.

The major annoyance is the fact that the written material (course outlines) is not included in the Great Course lectures. Yes, Audible made a disclaimer, but still, with so much information contained in these lectures, how can Audible expect listeners to properly gain enough knowledge without some written material? Simple things like how the names are spelled and which dates related to what events/figures are all part of the reason why written text is necessary for learning. I will have to buy his written text separately to compensate.

That said, I still highly recommend it because the lectures are just too good to miss.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

18 people found this helpful

Too Selective On Church History

There is much to profit from in this lecture, with one strong caveat I'll get to. Professor Bartlett is a great story teller and he alternates well between the macro and the micro in summarizing the Italian Renaissance. He treats us to details of personages and events, and he also aims to interpret those details and show how they caused history to develop as it did.

But, as a believing Roman Catholic, I thought he left a gaping hole in not describing the life and times of the faithful and their impact on the Italian Renaissance. When you focus so much on Power Politics, you neglect to see the impact of lived faith. The lives of the saints were quite prominent during this period -- individuals who were recognized for their impact on the world by acclamation of people who knew them. I am well aware of the sins of the clergy and the Popes during this period and Professor Bartlett will rightly detail those sins. My faith is not built on human beings. But you will not hear much about the saints or the lives of the faithful which did much to make the Renaissance what it was, too.

Some historians seem to fear they may sound too sectarian in offering those details. But the historian's job is to present details and assign causes to events, irrespective of the source of those causes. One need not be a Catholic to be a historian of Catholic events. But one cannot be a historian of Catholic events if one excludes details of Catholic life and faith from consideration, when those details are also important causes of events. In my estimation, Professor Bartlett did so here and his work would have been more complete, and equally interesting to believer and non-believer alike, if he had augmented it with details of the lived experience of faith during these times. The Church is always something more than just Power Politics, even if, at times, it may be that.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

12 people found this helpful

Superb lecturer, detailed educational experience

It has been half a century since I graduated from college. The course took me back to the educational pleasure of listening to a superb teacher explain a complicated topic, actually many complicated topics, and thoroughly enjoy learning new ideas, learning of new historical figures and placing a historical era into my life. Thank you

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

A thing of beauty

Professor Bartlett teaches these lectures with enthusiasm and imparts knowledge as a kind of gift. To be sure, it is his obvious love of the Italian Renaissance that makes the entirety of the lectures a sparkling jewell to be cherished.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Riveting and Enriching

This professor is elite.
He is passionate about the material, deeply knowledgeable, and a talented eloquent communicator.


Part of me wished that a bit more time could have been spent discussing the specifics of what made certain masterpieces so magnificent (eg why was the Mona Lisa so genius?) and part of me wished that the relationship to other cultures could have been explored more (eg... is Shakespeare a product of the Renaissance? Did England benefit from the Italian Renaissance? If so, how?.... eg how was it that the Portuguese managed to beat the pants off the Italians in exploration if the Italian Renaissance represented such a vibrant and unique atmosphere of intellectuality and innovation?)



Nevertheless, this course is magnificent... I learned so much and enjoyed it immensely.

Highly recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Renaissance come alive

This course is extremely informative and well presented, it gives a vivid picture of the Renaissance. Listening to these lectures you get a good understanding of the Renaissance period and of the people that lived in it. It has changed the way I used to think of this period. Well worth listening to!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Interesting but Something's Missing

This is a very interesting course that I greatly enjoyed. The professor is talented, and he presented a lot of information that I did not know. My one criticism is the notable absence of any in-depth discussion of the great Italian artists of the Renaissance. This is not so much a history of the Renaissance as it is a history of Italy during the Renaissance period. Nevertheless, I enjoyed the course, and feel like I learned a great deal. I recommend it to anyone...just don't expect to hear much about Leonardo or Raphael.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

An outstanding series

I have listened to a lot of courses in the Great Courses catalog, and this one is at the top of my list. It tracks the course of the Renaissance in Italy from the first stirrings of life in the early 1300s through the hard times of the 1500s that issued in a new cultural era. It affords a big picture view, but also includes specific stories of places and people that are all wonderfully interesting. I have had an interest in this subject all my life, but this course helped make sense of the story in a new way for me. It is a fascinating view of one of the major turning points in Western Civilization, presented in an logical. well-organized way, and engaging way. It fully deserves the high rating that listeners have given it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Excellent

Well organized. Delivered intelligently with enthusiasm. Argued his subjective interpretations well. Strangely sparse on discussing art and artists.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

A little too academic for me....

Would you consider the audio edition of The Italian Renaissance to be better than the print version?

Don't know

What did you like best about this story?

Its overall approach is very interesting

Which character – as performed by Professor Kenneth R. Bartlett – was your favorite?

Not relevant

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

The very beginning

Any additional comments?

It just reads to much like a very dry academic text book. I have not felt this way about a number of other great course that I have listened to.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful