Enjoyable though long winded

a good story but full of pointless tales told by characters met along the way

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A Masterwork from a truly wonderful writer.

Time to take a good look and just for once 'see' how fragile human life can be. Elements of Hardy's elemental fate and Conrad's simple refusal to try and know what can't really be known combine in a desert setting which puts everyone and everything 'out there' and on their own.

McCarthy's voice is always probing into areas that we rarely allow ourselves to go, recognising - if not the futility of existence - then surely the fact that we are all up against it in the struggle to move forwards.

Everything comes together in a book which never descends into philosophical 'abstraction' but just asks us to look a bit more closely at people and then move on. And it is this sense of movement - this momentum - which drives the narrative along, always seeking that something which may be over the horizon. And there is a lot of horizon in the desert lands of New Mexico and beyond.

If we were to value reading/listening as representing some form of escapism then you can do no better than this.

Wonderful narrator although I had to slow him down a bit to capture the 'space' which must accompany any reading of McCarthy. And the book two of a trilogy placement is completely irrelevant. This is simply a continuation of McCarthy's vision - the one that starts way back over there just past that arroyo and stretches as far as that cordillera over there with snow showing in places.

Simply magnificent - we all need to 'lose' ourselves at some time.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

poetic and philosophical.

Compelling, and poetic in it's imagery with lots of philosophical observations about life and human nature. Always interesting and thought provoking. There are lots of long passages written in Spanish which can be somewhat confusing, unless you understand Spanish of course. The narrator was excellent.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Brilliant

A universally perfect novel. Difficult to think of a novel that captures so much of our shared human experience. McCarthy takes on the big questions. Why are we here? Where are we going? Why do we do what we do? Based in the 1950ts and set to the back drop of the old west frontier.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Authentic & Enchanting

This book feels like an experiment for McCarthy, but it' my favourite from this author.

The story shifts between authentic depictions of the characters' journey between Mexico and US and the inner voyages of the various storytellers encountered on the road. The technique of story within story is very well used and recreates many layers of psychological and emotional depth.

There is a lot of violence (including against animals. which I found hard to bear) and a pervading sorrow in the travels undertaken by the main character, which seem to reflect, in a glimpse, the metaphor of the journey of life.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

It Couldn't Be Better

This is by far the best read audiobook I've ever heard. Richard Poe is perfect from start to finish. I think I'd find it hard to listen to anyone else read Cormac McCarthy now.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Impressive Coming of Age tale

Another great story by McCarthy about coming of age and the hidden feelings of man.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

.

I was born in America, but events during Vietnam took my drafted father to north Yorks hire...........england. I may be put too much stall in displacement......... But this writing has made me understand something of the human condition and how that vast land has defined us as a species .my favorite writer my favorite book

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Beautiful and heart wrenching

Beautifully told.
I’m working my way through the border trilogy. I feel like All the Pretty Horses was a warm up for this.
This book contains many stories within the main story as this is a story of the road & all the tales that come along it. This story is beautiful and heart wrenching.
I’m looking forward to the next one.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Epic tale

Cormac McCarthy writes a good story. The second installment of this trilogy is as evocative of the era as the first.
I read the book some years ago but this in no way detracted from the listening, indeed I will happily listen again in years to come. An advantage of reading the book was the ability to flick through pages when the occasional character: Mexican peasant or gypsy present their rambling philosophy of life. We're it not of these interludes I would certainly award the book five stars *****
Time to revisit volume three . . . . just not for a little while.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful