Helps the dots of history to today.

Alan Taylor, in his dedication to helping us understand our own origins as a nation, is one of the most patriotic historians we will ever have. The greatest threat to any nation, religion, or even relationship occurs when people and movements try to advance a destructive, selfish agenda under the false flag of a shared, cherished principle such as freedom, equality, or even religious faith. While we may not agree as to who are the current bearers of the false flags, this dynamic is something every American would probably agree threatens society today. In a fast-moving, engaging style, Taylor logically lays out how false flags were sewn, raised, and waved in the time period this book covers to justify slavery and dispossession of native lands. This is hardly an attack on the people of America as he quotes countless people -white, black, and native- who speak out against those waving the false flags.

The book explains so much of the period, step by step. Taylor shows how that fear that if Britain and France were left to control territory on the continent, they could destroy the union. This fueled Americans rush to dispossess Indians of their lands. Similarly, people feared that if all the land were not under American control in the hands of slave states or states with fugitive slave laws, slaves could escape and then help others to revolt against whites and escape. You see that Manifest Destiny in its time was not so much a visionary prediction as a defensive position. You will learn about black and white abolitionists and about white people opposed slavery in the west, not because they were moral, but simply because they feared the power of the large plantation owner to control the wealth in the way corporations can today. Over and over again, you see where the stated reasons for slavery and the violent dispossession of land were cloaked as “freedom to have property” or “saving the savages”. Again, the author makes the case by using the words of the many moral Americans who wrote and spoke against the hypocrisy and brutality within the time period. He reveals the threats to liberty and justice for all by using the words of people who spoke up on behalf of those principals.

You learn about how urbanization and the separation from the workers and owners unfolded, the beginnings of the Mormons, how Andrew Jackson came to be Andrew Jackson and how he created a coalition of working people and how that coalition later falls apart. You will see how land was taken from Native Americans through pseudo-legal means. He covers the Southwest, including how the ranchos were created from the missions, how white people from the East and from Europe came to obtain these ranchos. There is the birth of the different Texases, California, and Oregon. The unfolding of the Mexican-American War, and the lead-up to the Civil War. If you want a handle on this time period, presented in a very cause and effect way, this book is an excellent overview that will foster many questions and much further reading in your mind. Read it! It’s a great book that will give you a much clearer understanding of the past and better ability to explain to yourself and others how we got here. It’s an informative and a super easy read/listen.

7 people found this helpful

Well researched, but unreasonably biased

This author has studied US history during the noted period in an amazing level of detail. The accounts of statements made and trends at the time is very good. I’m happy to have consumed these accounts. Where the book doesn’t add up for me regards the overwhelming reporting of any and all information disparaging to the people and culture of the time. There is no denying that this author has accurately found things said and done, but I question the historical balance. If one consumes this author's account (which entails over and over and over and over really despicable behavior) with modern day ethos, morals, and judgement, then a conclusion can be that the US was a terribly awful place in the late 1700s and early 1800s. [Well of course it was horrible. No electricity, sanitation, modern medicine. And since the dawn of man, the world was practicing slavery without question. Awful.] Historians wanting to describe life in the US during past centuries will conduct their study and decide what info to include to produce an account that achieves a purpose. After hours and hours of this book, I was convinced that the author had a heavy bias. I don’t know the reason, but I do know that the book is tainted by this bias. And here is what doesn’t add up to me. If the US, as of 1850, was the horribly mean, evil, and racist country that this author "paints", then how is it possible that the US does what it did just a few years later? If the author is (on balance) accurate, how did enough of the US decide slavery must be abolished? Why would a president risk all and stand for the cause? Why would a country fight a ghastly civil war with 600,000 casualties (~1.5 million with associated disease) if the majority position of the citizens were based in a culture that was evil and racist? I cannot reconcile this authors account with what I know to be fact regarding the evolution of the US. It’s like an author in the year 2200 digging up every bad thing said and done in south Chicago ~2022 (and by Trump & Co. just to add some nasty politicians in the mix) and writing a book that portrays this as some kind of norm for the US.

3 people found this helpful

“White Supremacy” would have been a better title

The book seemed almost completely focused on White Supremacy. If you are looking for historical facts to justify the progressive racial dogma of 2021, this is the book for you.

2 people found this helpful

Depressing history...

This is a long, sad story of personal ambition and ruthless land grabs. We owe the Native Americans more than we can ever repay.

Superb

Alan Taylor is a national treasure. His work is deeply researched, extensively footnoted and exquisitely written.

Eye-opening!

This is a period of American history with which I was unfamiliar so I chose to read this after seeing some positive reviews. It is an excellent, well-written, informative and eye-opening take on this critical period of American expansionism prior to the Civil War. Highly recommend this book…also excellent narration.

A Portrait, not a political history

This book has a variable range of ratings. What I think is the cause is that this (as the title says), is a Continental history. Mr. Taylor has given us a portrait of America from revolution to the eve of the civil war. This is an important distinction as it reflects more about the humans living on the continent and less on the so called “philosophical debates” which was sophistry explaining our “peculiar” history. This is a corrective of how we truly acted and not how we wished it had been.
My quibble has to do with a bit of repetitiveness in some chapters that an editor should have caught. It was worth the time considering Taylor’s arguments and is recommended.

Excellent overview of the years that formed our nation

This is an excellent overview of the years that formed our nation. It is, at times, painful to listen to the pain and carnage we inflicted to those consider lesser humans. This deep understanding of what we did as a nation should be required reading to all.

The Down Side of America's History

Interesting and concise historical remdering of a formative period in America's emergence as a nation. Unfornately unbalenced as it emphasizes the most negative interpretations and motivations that drove the political process in the United States from its infancy in 1783 to 1850 on the the brink of a cival war.

not much to add over Taylor's other work

very disappointing given Taylor's other great works. i would not recommend. first negative review I've ever feft obliged to leave for an audio book.

In short, read his other fantastic works.