Episodes

  • CROSSOVER CHAOS WITH CAREY ODONNELL from SUP

    CROSSOVER CHAOS WITH CAREY ODONNELL from SUP
    Jun 9 2025
    After a whirlwind week of post-Jackie Warner interview fame, I escape into the shade of a WeHo park with one of my best friends and Fire Island housemate, Carey O'Donnell (SUP podcast), to regroup. In the shadow of SUR and the ghost of Sky Sport & Spa, we unpack Workout Season 2, Episode 2 while getting distracted by jacked strangers on the jungle gym. Topics include:
    • Post-Bravo fame burnout
    • The shifting sands of gay status symbols
    • West Hollywood vs Fire Island energy
    • And a deeply personal revelation involving Carey’s high school swim team
    Let’s just say... this episode has a lot of heart—and eye candy
    Show More Show Less
    37 mins
  • THE JACKIE WARNER INTERVIEW

    THE JACKIE WARNER INTERVIEW
    Jun 2 2025
    Jackie Warner. Bravo icon. Fitness pioneer. Reality TV legend. This is the conversation I never thought I’d get. After weeks of planning, last-minute chaos nearly derailed everything — first a parade ruined the audio, then Jackie got COVID, mercury was in retrograde and the mics we sent to Jackie refused to work.
    So I did what I had to: I mic’d my laptop speaker. And myself. What you’re about to hear is raw, imperfect, and completely real. We talk about Workout, fame, Jillian Michaels, her mother, Sky Sport & Spa, and the truth about where Jackie is now.
    It’s not polished.
    It’s not filtered.
    But what she told me was better than I could have ever hoped.
    It’s Jackie Warner, finally speaking.
    Show More Show Less
    41 mins
  • Season 2 Begins: Jackie Fever, (almost) Full Nudity & Bravo Brilliance (with Sarah Galli)

    Season 2 Begins: Jackie Fever, (almost) Full Nudity & Bravo Brilliance (with Sarah Galli)
    May 26 2025
    John Hill swore he'd stop at Season 1... but the Jackie Warner obsession has fully taken over. In this explosive kickoff to Season 2 of Show Pony, John spirals deeper into Bravo madness, wandering NYC like a Sky Sport & Spa-possessed zombie—and yes, he even gets naked for the YouTube fans. Joining him is Andy's Girls host and Bravo authority Sarah Galli, who’s been decoding reality TV for a decade. Together, they unpack the cultural legacy of Workout, the unrelenting power of Jackie Warner, and what it means when Bravo takes over your soul. Subscribe, strip down, and saddle up—because Season 2 is off to an absolutely unhinged start.
    Show More Show Less
    41 mins
  • EPISODE 6: Jackie Warner Makes Contact, Total Finale Meltdown with Natalie Joy Johnson and Eric Maxwell

    EPISODE 6: Jackie Warner Makes Contact, Total Finale Meltdown with Natalie Joy Johnson and Eric Maxwell
    May 19 2025
    It’s the Workout Season 1 finale, and everything goes off the rails. Jackie Warner was scheduled to appear on the podcast. Instead, she sent a shocking text (which we reenact in full). Then a parade outside destroyed our audio setup. Somehow, John Hill and Eric Maxwell powered through—spiraling live, trying to recap the finale and stay emotionally upright. Enter Broadway star and Bravo legend Natalie Joy Johnson, who shows up to deliver JOVANI realness and dish on borrowing dresses from Countess Luann herself. Together, we try to make sense of the season's end—and the glorious mess it took to get here. Follow @johnhilljohnhill + @njjisrelentless + @elephanteric
    Show More Show Less
    43 mins
  • BONUS: Jackie Cancels, a Parade Ruins Everything, and We Spiral (feat. Eric Maxwell)

    BONUS: Jackie Cancels, a Parade Ruins Everything, and We Spiral (feat. Eric Maxwell)
    May 19 2025
    This was supposed to be our Show Pony season finale with Jackie Warner. Instead… chaos. In this bonus full-length episode, John Hill and Eric Maxwell recap the behind-the-scenes disaster of the finale recording: Jackie drops out last minute (via a text we dramatically reenact), a parade destroys our audio, and we try to keep it together while recapping the final episode of Workout. This is the extended cut of a shorter conversation that appears in the main finale episode—a raw, hilarious spiral into unexpected territory. Watch the meltdown. Hear the chaos. Love the pony. Follow John on Instagram: @johnhilljohnhill
    Subscribe on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/JohnArthurHill
    Show More Show Less
    11 mins
  • EPISODE 5: A REAL BLIND DATE! (Just Like Jackie Warner)

    EPISODE 5: A REAL BLIND DATE! (Just Like Jackie Warner)
    May 12 2025
    John Arthur Hill takes his obsession with Bravo's Workout to a new level — by inviting a blind date to cohost this week’s Show Pony. Yes, this is their actual first date. On mic. No script. No safety net. Together they unpack Jackie Warner’s romantic storyline in Episode 5 of Workout, while navigating their own on-air chemistry. What starts as a recap turns into a meta reality show moment — equal parts awkward, hilarious, and unexpectedly tender. It’s Show Pony meets The Rehearsal meets Grindr roulette.
    Tune in for one of the boldest podcast stunts yet.
    Show More Show Less
    43 mins
  • EPISODE 4 - JOHN SNAPS

    EPISODE 4 - JOHN SNAPS
    May 5 2025
    SHOW PONY Ep. 4 – John Flies Across the Country to Stand Outside a Gym John has completely snapped.
    Fueled by a Bravo fitness obsession 20 years in the making, he impulsively travels cross-country just to loiter outside Sky Sport & Spa — the hallowed ground of Workout. Overwhelmed by his own madness, he calls Andy Cohen’s assistant (also a trusted lifelong lesbian) to emotionally process this very public, very personal spiral. 💥 It’s an episode full of bad decisions, emotional damage, and gym-based delusion.
    New episodes every Monday! Listen wherever podcasts rot your brain. #WorkoutBravo #SkySportSpa #RealityMeltdown #ShowPonyPodcast
    Show More Show Less
    35 mins
  • Where Is Jackie Warner? | Uncovering Lesbian Mysteries with Jess Rothschild |

    Where Is Jackie Warner? | Uncovering Lesbian Mysteries with Jess Rothschild |
    Apr 28 2025
    In Episode 3 of Show Pony, John Arthur Hill teams up with legendary pop culture detective and professional lesbian historian Jess Rothschild (Hot Takes and Deep Dives) to solve the greatest mystery of our time: Where is Jackie Warner? What starts as a Bravo rewatch turns into a dark, gripping, borderline obsessive investigation — complete with pulse-pounding theories, shocking revelations, and absurdly serious commentary on a very unserious subject. If you love true crime vibes, Bravo nostalgia, dark humor, and unhinged queer storytelling, this episode is your new crime scene. New episodes of Show Pony drop every Monday night — subscribe wherever you get your podcasts, and follow @showponytv for behind-the-scenes mayhem.
    Show More Show Less
    33 mins