Superbly researched and presented

It always feels weird using words like ‘enjoyed’ when talking about books with such heavy subject matter, but I will say this was very well researched and narrated. My main hope was that it would explore potential motives and issues with how evidence was presented as well as the individual cases and trials and it definitely did all that very thoroughly in a sympathetic (to the families) yet non-biased way. I would imagine it’s not easy to ask these difficult questions without coming across as exploitative but it feels like a lot of care was put into keeping things balanced in the later, more speculative sections.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

The Beige Banality of Evil

Lucy Letby evokes strong opinions from the public. This audiobook is a well-balanced account of her case, which I think could be accepted by people on both sides of the guilty - not guilty divide as it presents arguments for and against guilt.

For anyone not too familiar with the detail of the case I think it is a good primer and will bring you up to speed on the detail.

I am familiar with the detail of the case. I started following the case during the original trial so I have listened to the whole trial podcast in real time; I read the internet forums daily with reports from people who had gone to the court and were giving accounts of what they saw and heard (subject to any court restrictions); I have listened to the verbatim transcripts of her time on the witness box and of her police interviews, which are available on YouTube. So I didn't particularly learn anything new about the trial, but i enjoyed the fact that in this book, the authors pulled together all of those strands into a cohesive narrative.

There was also some new content with interviews with Letby's friends, medical experts and psychological experts.

I was hoping there would be more on Letby's psychology and what would make her do these things. In the book the conclusion seems to be that we don't know particularly. I think that is perhaps a product of this book being written too quickly after the conclusion of the trial and retrial, such that we are still finding out more information about Letby.

The Thirlwell Inquiry is currently in progress and already some of what is coming out of that contradicts/undermines the content of this book. For instance we now know Letby failed her final studies, so she wasn't the great student everyone said; her adult 'best friend' who was a fellow nurse, told the Inquiry that through the trial she discovered that Letby had been lying to her; various individuals thought they were Letby's only confidante, only to find out via the trial and Inquiry that it wasn't the case at all; so she has been lying, also the Inquiry has highlighted even more odd behaviour from her family. This is all to say that I think the story of Letby is not over and some of the content of this audiobook is already out of date. Personally I think there must be more to the fact that she was a baby whose life had to be saved at birth, who ended up with overprotective parents, who hurt other babies who were at risk at birth, and thus their parents...

However the good thing with an audiobook is when they do a second edition with extra chapters to cover the new information (which I really hope they will do, they must, it is fascinating what is coming out), you don't usually have to buy it as your audiobook should be automatically updated.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A well planned and thought out in-depth study of the Lucy Letby case.

It is a thought provoking book which goes into the evidence of air embolism and insulin poisoning in great but understandable detail, the book also looks at Lucy’s personality and discusses the view of her supporters in depth.

For anyone interested in finding out more about the case it’s worth a listen and is well narrated.

The only negative is that a pdf is available for download which I thought would be pictures and maybe some examples of the evidence shown to the jury, it’s a list of .wav files which is as much use as a chocolate fireguard.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Brilliant book

Incredibly well researched and balanced. I have listened to and read a lot about this case and there was lots more information here. Probably one of the best true crime books I've listened to - and that's a lot! A must-listen if you're interested in this case.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Very informative

Left with a question . How many vials if insulin needed to obtain such high results and does that correspond with stock levels ? Cannot believe that discrepancy not noticed by pharmacy stock checks

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An In-Depth Look at a Complex Case

I recently finished this book and it left me thoroughly impressed. While it presents some challenging sections, the effort required is absolutely rewarding. The courtroom accounts of the trial are particularly fascinating, immersing readers in the gripping details of the legal proceedings.

Judith and Jonathan excel in their narrative, skillfully guiding us through the intricacies of the case with clarity and insight. Their storytelling is both engaging and informative, making even the most complex aspects of the trial accessible. The depth of research they have undertaken is truly admirable, providing a well-rounded perspective that enhances our understanding of the events.

What sets this book apart is its focus on Lucy Letby, offering readers a chance to delve into her background and motivations. Through meticulous documentation and thoughtful analysis, we gain a deeper insight into her character and the circumstances surrounding the trial. This exploration invites us to grapple with the complexities of the case, prompting reflection on broader themes of justice and accountability.

For those interested in true crime or legal narratives, this book is a compelling read that challenges our perceptions and encourages critical thinking. Highly recommended for anyone looking to engage with a profound and thought-provoking account.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A sad read .. but compelling

A well read book with balanced viewpoints .. there will always be a slight element of doubt as she was not caught “in the act” but the evidence does seem compelling

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Compelling Listening.

Immaculate story telling by the two authors - I looked forward to listening to this horrific true story as it unfolded chapter by chapter.
There is more to this story & I look forward to the next book being published.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Comprehensive and engaging

A detailed account of the Letby case, including a thorough consideration of potential evidence and alternative information. Interesting and engaging. Would recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

very well l researched and presented

This was very well presented and extremely interesting. it was very well put together with clear arguments and explanations. I was on the fence before, I now know fully what I believe...

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!