Absolutely wonderful story !

What did you love best about Threads of Silk?

It is a lovely story that follows one main character from the age of six well into her senior years and also follows the historical events during that time period. The story peaked my interest in a place and time that I was unfamiliar with and I often found myself stopping the book to do a little side research to expand my knowledge. The main character was so well written and the story so nicely developed that it had me questioning whether this main character was a real person in history.

What other book might you compare Threads of Silk to and why?

Any book in Ken Follett's Pillars of Creation or Century trilogy. These books, as well as Threats of Silk, are wonderful stories intertwined amongst history to create a very realistic tale. The research that went into creating the characters and plot must've been astounding.

What does Leanne Yau bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Correct pronunciation of the places and people's in the story.

Another reviewer commented that Leanne Yau had an American accent, it is actually English. It was also mentioned that it was a disappointment that she spoke without a Chinese accent because the main character could not speak English. Personally, I do not have an issue with the fact that this book is narrated with an English accent because I speak English and I would not have understood the book if it was read to me in Chinese (which would be only way to stay true to a character that does not speak English).

Any additional comments?

I was given this free review copy audiobook at my request and voluntarily left this unbiased review

I would love to listen to another book by this author or narrator.

10 people found this helpful

Great story but needs a new narrator.

It was a great story but was really hard to get around the accent of the narrator.

4 people found this helpful

❤️

A really beautiful book. Wonderfully well written characters and story that I loved. I took my time listening just so I didn't miss anything. I really loved the whole feel of this book. Very enjoyable.

The narrator did an awesome job. Wonderful performance.

This audiobook was provided by the author, narrator, or publisher at no cost in exchange for an unbiased review.

4 people found this helpful

Enchanting story and narration

An enchanting story told from a fascinating perspective. Through Yaqian's (sp?) eyes, we hear details of daily life at the end of an era. I loved the details of time and place in this story--I won't list any examples here though (no spoilers!)

The narrator did a terrific job as well. I love the timbre of this narrator's voice. Her voice has a smooth cadence, not too fast, not too slow, and varied inflection that always keeps the story moving forward. She brings the different characters to life with different voices. I plan to search for other works she may have narrated, because the narration can really make or break a story and this one is a keeper!

3 people found this helpful

Fascinating story of mid-late 19th century China

Any additional comments?

This is the first historical fiction story that I've read which is set in mid- to late- 19th century China. Purists can sometimes be dismissive of historical fiction because of the creative license taken by authors when it comes to fact vs. fiction. I suppose I can understand their position, if readers end up with distorted or incorrect understanding of historical events. On the other hand, good historical fiction can spark an interest and curiosity that prompts readers to explore the topic in more depth on their own after the story ends - and that can be a wonderful rabbit hole to jump into...

And that's where I found myself after reading this book (during the book, too). A few times, I'd put the audiobook on pause so that I could do some more internet research about the actual people in the story - Parkes, Empress Dowager Cixi, Prince Gong, and more. I also did some browsing about foot binding, embroidery, the Boxer Rebellion, and Han vs Manchu Chinese. The tale of the heroine, an embroidery girl at Court, formed a narrative backbone that linked and launched all of my interesting research side trips. For sparking my curiosity and holding my interest throughout the book, I give this story full stars. The only reason why I deducted a star was because the protagonist had some flaws that made her less than admirable in my eyes. She's only human, of course, but I didn't really relate to her or engage emotionally with her. So I felt, as a reader, that I was outside looking in on her life and experiences. I could sympathize, but not empathize.

The narrator did a great job. As mentioned, this is my first foray into audio historical fiction from this place and time. So I was expecting an English speaking narrator with a Chinese accent. Instead, the narration was British-accented English. It picked at the back of my mind throughout the story - is this what an English speaking person in China would have sounded like, or is the accent British because that's the narrator's own voice? The protagonist in the story was an uneducated country-bred Chinese girl who couldn't speak English, so I couldn't really reconcile the narrator's tone with what I imagined to be an authentic voice of the protagonist. Regardless, the narrator spoke with a flowing tone and pace, and I enjoyed the sound of her voice. Sometimes it was hard to distinguish some of the speakers, but there were quite a few different female characters so I understand that it might be challenging to give each of them their own voice (I noticed this particularly when a female character was "freaking out" during a conversation). Aside from this, though, I'd certainly listen to this narrator again. I'm Canadian and I love hearing British accents!

Some other reviewers have commented about a few very graphic sex scenes in the story. There were only a few of them, and it's easy enough to fast forward to the end of those parts. If I were to change anything about the story, I would want an epilogue that extended the narrative for a little while longer, so we could learn what happened to our protagonist towards the end of her life. There were significant changes happening in China, after all. By the time we get to the final chapter, pretty much all of the main players in the story have exited from the stage and she has given her assets to her grandchild so she doesn't have much financial security. So, I'd have liked the author to have given us a little peek into her future.

Otherwise, I thought that this was a wonderful story and I'm not going to delete it from my audiobook library anytime soon.

"I was given this free review copy audiobook at my request and have voluntarily left this review."

3 people found this helpful

Did not keep my attention...

This audiobook was just okay for me. I was really drawn into the story initially, but I think the scope of the narrative became too broad about half way through and I started to lose my sense of who the protagonist was and what she really wanted. I am not an expert on Chinese history and cannot comment on the accuracy of the historical material, but the book is very detailed in its treatment of cultural practices.

The narration was well performed and I particularly enjoyed Leanne Yau's approach to dialogue. Her characterizations were clear without being over the top, and it was easy to follow, However, it was poorly edited (i.e. quite a few instances where entire sentences or phrases were repeated rather than edited out), and I found it distracting.

2 people found this helpful

All the drama of China’s history

This is an amazing story. If you have any interest in China’s history then this is a must read. The entire story is first person of a girl growing up in China and the transformations she goes through from choices forced upon her as well as her own good or bad decisions that have natural consequences. Amanda Roberts is an excellent storyteller and knows just how to keep her readers interest.

Leanne Yau does an excellent job reading this story. Her voice fits the characters and she can even pronounce the names that I would have no clue about if I were reading myself. I would call her accent a bit British but that is likely true of Asian English and so fits the story as well.

I was voluntarily provided this free review copy audio book by the author, narrator, or publisher.

2 people found this helpful

Narrator with a British Accent???!!!

The story was very interesting but it did lack some details about what the main character was feeling. But what I can’t understand is why on earth did they choose a narrator with a British accent for a book about a Chinese woman??? When I visualized the characters I had to keep reminding myself they were Chinese and not European. It ruined the whole feeling of the book. Very unfortunate. Her narration wasn’t bad but she was the wrong choice for this particular book.

1 person found this helpful

A lot of story for one book

The story itself is fine and I love the characters. I learned a lot about ancient China and it's customs. However I felt there was more than enough content to write two or three more books. Instead of having the main character skim over months and years worth of storyline, I wish the author would've taken more time to actually write it out as part of the story. The narrator took some getting used to as her voice is quite nasally and only has about two or three vocal variations. She reads well but it was a bit awkward hearing a European accent narrating a story set in East Asia with an Asian lead stating that she doesn't understand English.

1 person found this helpful

narrator off story a miss

I endured 8 hours of this story wanting to like it....but didn't
the narrator didn't match the theme of the story but I don't think a new narrator would have helped the story. I don't understand the higher ratings.
it covered so many topics feet binding tribal factions many wives concubines without any depth just went on and on

1 person found this helpful