Harrowing but Brilliant

I've read this book a few times and was keen to listen to it also.
It is such a dark and depressing story but also full of personal strength. Young Mary (as Head in the Welsh accent) does what she can to survive. Her ambitions are high and far away but she tries. Sadly the ending is not as she hoped.

Great telling of Emma Donoghue's story.
And still my favourite book of hers.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Beautiful reading of this believable story

I loved the historical setting, the use of language and the narration. I really enjoyed the middle part of the story but the ending wasn’t what I was hoping for.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

I loved this but maybe not to everyone's taste..

'hats off straight away for gentle & lilting but characterful narration - so well done and wholly right for the story, for the time, the place and most of all for 'Mary'.

I selected this on the basis of 'Room' but any comparison would be apples & pears..!

This is the life-story of Mary. As an only child who is 'fallen', Mary is sent away & must learn survival on the city's harshest backstreets - this world together with the loss & rejection of her parents, shapes her.
When later there is opportunity for safety and quiet, can Mary un-learn the hardest of lessons life has taught her..should she look for & can she live with compromise; can there be for her, social approval, belonging & peace of mind?

This book has a real sense of era - I could almost smell those foul backstreets then feel the rich white velvet, the softness of Jane & the finger-prick of the seamstresses needle..

The storyline 'pauses' in part to colour-in the minutiae of everyday life - a slower pace that might not suit all listeners. I was perfectly happy though, plodding on, enjoying the slow building of relations & communication & the contradictions for and within the troubled young woman who is Mary; beautifully written I think & Id recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Superb

I absolutely loved this book. Set in the late 1700s; it's a story of a young girl's tragic life with lots of twists, turns and shocks. You really get a feel of what life would have been like at this time if you were out on your luck. The narrator was excellent and really brought the story to life.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Brilliant in Every Respect

Completely absorbing as it is well told, as well as being very accurate regarding the time in which it was set; no tautologies, to make you wince! The narration is outstanding and I shall definitely look out for this narrator in future.
I haven't enjoyed a book so much for a long time and can thoroughly recommend it.- pure quality.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Slammerkin

Slammerkin is the name for a loose fitted garment worn by women in the 1700,s.The title hints at the loose morals of this century,the story itself tells of the corruption of an innocent child who makes one crucial mistake and ends up paying for it with her life.

Mary's story is told by the author in such a way that

it is easy to conjure up the vivid images of the dirt and filth of the London streets,the lewd talk and behaviour of the characters.

In contrast to this bleakness is the introduction of the rural Wales,which gives the reader a glimmer of hope for Mary's character but alas her short life will not let her shake off her past sins.

I originally read this book about five years ago and at the time it left me feeling sad for the people of that time,but nothing really changes .life is easy for some and hard for others depending mostly on which bed you are born in. Looking around the world today there are young people living equally miserable existences,we havent eradicated the horror of not having the choice to live the life we really want .

The audio version somehow adds to the atmosphere of the time ,we have the sense of hearing to add another dimension.

Well worth reading or listening to ,Emma Donoghue has done an excellent job here .

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Bawdy history of an 18th century poor girl.

Very interesting and historically accurate account a prostitute. Enjoyed, couldn't stop listening and learnt much.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Such superb narration

A truly remarkable story, superbly told. Even more amazing is that it's a true story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Great story

I really enjoyed this book and loved the narrator. This is probably one of the best of its genre I've heard. The main character evolves as the story delelops and there are many twists and turns. She is quite an unusual heroine and I felt attached to her and intrigued.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Beautifully written but deeply harrowing

Set in London and Monmouth in the eighteenth century, Slammerkin is the story of Mary, a fourteen year old girl abandoned by her family and forced to resort to prostitution in order to survive. Be warned - it is often deeply harrowing. However, Emma Donoghue's eye for detail, coupled with her delight in language made even the darkest moments pulse with energy.



"The old man's tongue pushed past her lips as if looking for something, buried treasure. It tasted like a burnt thing. It thrashed like a dying fish and bruised the roof of her mouth. She thought she might choke."



This is an unflinching portrait of life at the bottom of a brutal society and from the first page, it's clear that things will not end well for Mary. Yet I kept on hoping until the very end, because despite all the squalor, there is so much that is life-affirming in these pages, and because the characters are so recognisably human. You feel you know them all so well and you desperately want their plans to prosper. Sadly, very few of them do.



The narration by Charlotte Stevens was first class: beautifully clear and fully engaged.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful