A series of bad decisions

Historical fiction is normally my go-to reading/listening choice, so I was excited about the prospect of reading this speculative fiction about Leonardo da Vinci's upbringing. We know few documented facts about his mother and early childhood, so a riff on this part of his life is intriguing. The unfolding of this story is interesting; Leonardo's grandfather is a learned scholar and an apothecary in a small village and his only child and daughter is home schooled, well-educated, and his helper in his business. The 14-year-old girl makes the first of a long series of bad decisions by falling in love with and becoming pregnant by Leonardo's immature young father, the son of a wealthy and social-climbing family with ties in Florence.

The tale seems to be well-researched, and peppered with just the right amount of descriptions of life in this period. What begins as a good story arc starts to wobble after a couple of hours, and becomes driven by a succession of bad decisions, forced coincidences, and improbable plot twists that are increasingly implausible (no spoilers). At hour number five, I had to stop reading. Leonardo's plucky mother and the direction of the story were headed into situations that were so unlikely for that period in Florentine history that I couldn't make myself believe that they were remotely possible. Perhaps if I'd been able to suspend disbelief and keep reading, the story would have mended itself.

1 person found this helpful

Not what I expected

This was picked as a book club book and I wasnt very thrilled, however, I was pleasantly surprised to thoroughly enjoy the storyline and the reader giving the audio presentation.

1 person found this helpful

Beautiful! Journey into a fascinating past world!

Any additional comments?

I love this original story, wonderful fiction peppered with breathtaking historical details and takes you on a journey to a fascinating past world-Renaissance Italy.

Interesting story about a woman (Da Vinci's mother) perseverance in a society where women had few choices and very little power. Yes, there is romance, but it is an integral part of a woman's life, particularly in a time when it was almost impossible to survive without a man at her side- so in my opinion it is appropriate to the story.

Narration was good, and I couldn't stop listening!

Story: 5 stars, excellent historical fiction with some appropriate romance!
Narration: 4 stars
Relationship: appropriate development and some romance.

Overall: beautiful, definitely worth a credit and your time!

1 person found this helpful

Lost steam.

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

No, I wouldn't recommend it. Although it had some very interesting parts about DaVinci and the history of Florence, it degenerated into a "B" romance story very quickly.

What was your reaction to the ending? (No spoilers please!)

Didn't make it that far.

What about Bernadette Dunne’s performance did you like?

She did a good job at different character voices and at presenting emotional inflections at appropriate times.

Was Signora da Vinci worth the listening time?

Meh. I'll probably finish it eventually, but it wasn't worth the credit.

1 person found this helpful

Too much Harlequin Romance

I expected a historical novel and felt like I got a romance novel set in the 1400s. I do like Jane Austen and the historical mystery romances by Tasha Alexander, so I'm not anti-romance. But, I did not like Signora da Vinci and only listened to about 1/4. I wanted to like it. I planned to listen to it while flying to Italy this summer and it seemed perfect:, but I just couldn't finish it. The author seemed to have done her research and the premise was interesting, but it came across as fluffy and breathless- perhaps my opinion was negatively influenced by the narrator's style...

1 person found this helpful

Fantastic book

I thoroughly enjoyed this book. It was written well and it allowed me to truly feel the characters thoughts and feelings. I couldn't put it down. I highly recommend!

Fascinating and cant stop listening

Found this book very interesting and entertaining. This is one I may listen to again.