good book, unconvincing narrator.

An excellent book but where on earth did you get the narrator.? Pronunciation errors throughout.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A RESTRAINED ACCOUNT - UNTIL BREXIT!!

Fearful Cochranes account of the turbulent history of NI was helpful, fulsome and peppered with key insights. For the most part he was balanced and fair, until he dealt with Brexit - then he lost the plot with a welter of observations that made you think Armaggeden was on the horizon. The reality is that national history doesn't stop because one piece of legislation changes. He recovered some poise towards the end with the hopeful emergence of the Alliance Party. Overall a comprehensive account.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Good book spoilt by the Narrator

This book is a very cogent review of the recent history of Northern Ireland and a valuable contribution to the literature on the subject. As someone who has lived his adult life throughout "The Troubles", I found it very helpful as a general analysis. That said, I think insufficient time has passed for a true history of the period to be written. That is the task for future historians.

I think the author is on shakier ground in the later chapters of the book when he deals with the very recent past particularly with reference to Brexit. His fears that it is an existential threat to the Good Friday Agreement (GFA) are I believe, exaggerated. For all its shortcomings, it is now imbedded in the political system in the Province. All Parties pay at least lip service to the Power Sharing arrangements that are its essence. Sinn Fein and the DUP were both shocked by the reaction of the Public to their failure in forming an Executive in a survey in late 2019. This lead very quickly to its formation shortly afterwards. The issues over the NI Protocol will no doubt put a strain on it, but both sides know there is no alternative. The reasons as to how we got to this situation will no doubt be studied at a later date but for the present a good summary would be - DUP Cockup.

I would also take issue with his undue emphasis on the role of sectarianism in NI. It does of course exist, how could it not? given our history, but it does not permeate ordinary life here to the extent he suggests. Large tranches of the population, and not only the professional/middle classes get by fine with "the other side". Academics like journalists tend to concentrate on what divides us.

However, my biggest complaint by far is about the audible version of this book and the narrator Roger Clark. This book is about Northern Ireland and the narrator should have been someone from there. Mr Clark's thick Irish accent grated on me throughout and frankly struck me as phoney. This together with his regular mispronunciation of a number of words raised my suspicions. These were confirmed when I looked him up on the Net and sure enough it transpires he is American and his natural accent at least on You Tube is east coast American. In the end to finish the book, I ended up buying a hard copy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Interesting and insightful

Learnt new things and deepened my understanding. Also good to hear Mo Mowlam properly acknowledged.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Bigoted Rubbish

Republican propaganda. Bias bigoted Rubbish throughout. I was not allowed to return. Not recommended. Avoid

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful