Where's Kane?

Would you consider the audio edition of Masques to be better than the print version?

They are equally good, but I love Katherine Kellgren's interpretation. I listen to this book and it's sequel, Wolfsbane, over and over.

What was one of the most memorable moments of Masques?

When Wolf rescues Aralorn from the ae'Magi's castle.

What about Katherine Kellgren and Patricia Briggs (introduction) ’s performance did you like?

It was interesting to hear the evolution of this book. I have only lately discovered Patricia Briggs through the Mercy Thompson books, so I have never read the original.

Katherine Kellgren does a stellar job. Her voice is soothing and easy to listen to, but she manages to convey the cynical Wolf, the unctious Geoffrey ae'Magi, the earnest Myr and the miscellaneous denizens of Myr's refugee camp with aplomb, bringing them all to life with her characterizations.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?

Can two mercenaries save the kingdom?

Any additional comments?

I really enjoy this book, even though it was reworked from an earlier publication and has some rough spots. These characters are like comfort food - they just make you feel good.

19 people found this helpful

A decent first effort

I absolutely ADORE Patricia Briggs. I love her Mercy Thompson and Alpha & Omega series --- they are both automatic buys/pre-orders. (In fact... I have them in paperback, kindle, and audio formats.) I HIGHLY recommend those.

In anycase... Masques is a re-release of her first novel and even though it has been tweaked/cleaned up some, it still lacks something. The story line is okay - though a bit choppy at times - and the main characters are interesting, but neither is as fleshed out as much as I would like. One of the things I like best about Briggs is how invested I become in all her characters... even secondary ones. I think this is perhaps the area that I can see the greatest improvement in how she has grown as a writer. ( Seriously... this woman has had me in tears over the loss of minor characters and can make a piece of wood interesting. One of my favorite characters of hers is a walking stick.) Unfortunately, in THIS book... I did not find myself emotionally invested in many, if not most, of the characters. Thus, my rating is as follows:

Story --- 2.5 to 2.75 Narrator --- 4.5 Overall ---- 3

Having said all that, I have purchased & look forward to the sequel to this book.
And by ALL means... check out her other series.

35 people found this helpful

Satisfying tale, interesting characters

Masques is a comfort book. The kind of book you pull out on cold wet days and enjoy with a nice warm blanket and a cup of hot tea. While certainly no Tolkien, Robert Jordan or Anne McCaffrey, Patricia Briggs knows how to tell an emotionally satisfying tale.

We begin the audio book with an author read introduction which explains the real world context within which the book was written. I loved her final 'compromise', in that she admits to fleshing details in the book out with a rewrite, while taking nothing away from the original novel.

As far as the story itself, it is an emotionally satisfying tale, with main characters that are interestingly flawed. This is no epic, but it was enjoyable, and had a few interesting twists and surprises along the way. The two main characters had great chemistry, and the romance between them built comfortably and believably throughout the story.

As far as the reader, she did an excellent job maintaining individual voices for several of the key characters. Her timing and general storytelling skills were definitely great. Sometimes her 'excitement' when reading action passages was noticeable, but it didn't really detract from the story or my enjoyment of it at all.

To summarize: Satisfying, cozy story of sword, sorcery and romance.

38 people found this helpful

Good storyline

What three words best describe Katherine Kellgren and Patricia Briggs (introduction) ’s voice?

The narrator did well enough. I don't consider her one of the best in the business but she does well and keeps the story moving and engaging.

Any additional comments?

I was surprised by the story after the authors introduction about how this story wasn't supposed to be very good being one of her earlier works. I found the story engaging and interesting. I liked it enough to get the second book in the series.

7 people found this helpful

Unimpressive performance of a subpar novel

I really like Patricia Briggs's recent work, and had read most of it, as far back as Steal the Dragon. I thought Steal the Dragon was really, really rough, but still worth reading. Still, I wasn't sure about picking up her first novel, given how close Steal the Dragon was to my limit. But when I found out that she had revised it, I figured, okay, it's probably fine.

I was wrong. It's pretty bad. In fact, I'm not sure any amount of revision could fix what is wrong with this book, and she more or less admits that in the introduction.

The characters are one-dimensional, but even more, the writing style is just stickily stereotypical. The book shows flashes of promise, but I wonder how many of those were inserted later.

Frankly, if I'd been her, I wouldn't have released this. It's probably made her some money, but it's also probably made a number of people respect her less. In the end, I couldn't make it more than halfway through.

Skip it. Try one of her others instead.

14 people found this helpful

Great great read!

What made the experience of listening to Masques the most enjoyable?

The entire book was great, from beginning to end!

What was one of the most memorable moments of Masques?

When the 2 main characters fall for each other.

What does Katherine Kellgren and Patricia Briggs (introduction) bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

It was good to hear Patricia Briggs explain for herself what to expect of the revised version of the book. I've heard Katherine Kellgren read before, she was a little annoying at the beginning of this read. Her reading was really intense for to long of a period of time, I had to fight the urge to stop the book- when it really wasn't necessary for her to be that intense. But I do enjoy her accents that shes able to pull off.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Yes! I couldn't get enough of this book!!

6 people found this helpful

I love the love story.

More than anything else in this book, the love story stands out. Its not romantic or erotic, its two friends who spend years together, slowly building a close friendship that turns into love. Its a beautiful, realistic portrayal of a love that will last a lifetime. No "love at first site" crap that is so common in literature.

The rest of the story is also good, though a bit predictable. The villain in the story felt a little cartoonish.

5 people found this helpful

Solid fantasy adventure

Despite being the author's first book (and having some weaknesses she identifies in the preface), this is a pretty decent book, and I enjoyed it. The setting is good, if a little vague, and there are some novel elements in the magic. The story is not overly predictable, and the reader make a good presentation of it.

10 people found this helpful

Definitely a first novel

The story is predictable and uses ideas from other fantasy novels that are highly recognizable. But the worst part is the narrator. She sounds like she has a stick up her spine. Much too high and mighty a tone for the story line. I am not sure I will be able to finish listening to this as her voice is very irritating.

13 people found this helpful

A worthwhile first nove;

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

If you are someone who enjoys the fantasy genre and Patricia Briggs. this first novel is worth a listen. It is far from her best work but it is pleasant and you can see the seeds of her later work in it.

4 people found this helpful