One of my favorite Fantasy Series

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

In the book format, this was a series I could fall back into time and time again. The audible version has great narration that is flawless, I fell in love with the characters all over again and am looking forward for the rest of the books to come out.

What other book might you compare Magic Casement to and why?

Nothing really compares to the Man of His Word series, I compare other series to it. I guess you could compare Robin Hobb or Trudi Canavan, this is Dave Duncan's strongest work.

What does Mil Nicholson bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

This is the only book on Audible that I've heard Mil read, he does it like he's been doing it for years. He sounds like the voice in my head.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?

Magic, true love and an adventure that you will never forget.

Any additional comments?

Try this out, you won't be disappointed.

11 people found this helpful

Fansastic story in a fantastic world.

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

Although the book might sound typical, with a princess, a castle, a magical history, and an stableboy as an unlikely hero , they way author Dave Duncan sets up the rules of the world is interesting. Magic Casement introduces you to the players, and starts to introduce the world to the characters, and to the reader.

The first thing that you notice are that there are no "humans" as a separate race. There are Imps, and Jotnar, and Elves, and Goblins, and Gnomes, and others, all of which are just people.

Second, there is magic... the kingdom of Kagaznagar where the story takes place was created by a powerful wizard... But there are rules to magic, and it all centers on "Words of Power", and the great Warlocks and Witches in the capitol of the Impire. But these are things that the residents of remote Kagaznagar care little for, and know even less about.

But when the king Holindarn becomes ill, it sets in motion an incredible adventures for the Princess Inosolan, and he childhood friend, and stable-boy, Rap. As Inosolan is introduces to fine living, and the expectations of royalty, Rap is thrown into the disgusting and horrid world of goblins. As they experience more of the world around them, they begin to understand how precarious their kingdom, and even their lives, actually are.

This is the first book or 4, so it does start a little slow, and it seems to end rather abruptly. On its own, it would need to be longer. As part 1 of 4... its a good opening, and a worthwhile listen.

What about Mil Nicholson’s performance did you like?

Mil Nicholson does a good job of keeping the voices and accents separate and distinct, and her British accent lends an aura to this reading. She does the ladies' and boyish voices well, but seems to be a little lacking in some of the men's voices.

9 people found this helpful

I love this series!!

I first read this series long ago. I have been waiting for ages for it to come out in audio format. It is as good as I remember. I couldn't put it down. I am hoping for the last book to come out soon. This is one I could listen to over and over.

7 people found this helpful

A Princesss, the stable boy and the shapeshifter

For me Dave Duncan worlds always are set somewhere in our own world then expanded by a touch of magic. Actually in this case much more than a touch. Here is a mostly Celtic set at the high of the another Empire (much like later Rome Imperim).

I liked the main character - cheering for many. None are too sweet and they believable flawed. The book is wonderful and if the story is not totally original it is satisfactory told.

For Duncan normal habits are broken a bit - told story is told from a couple of character views; magic is a much bigger deal than in the Venise or Seventh Swords series. But the magic is clearly understandable rules and in keeping with general modern ideas of Celtic magic.

My only problem with the book is that it ends so quickly that one feels that there should be a second download not another book. Not totally cliff hanger just rather incomplete ending.

5 people found this helpful

Fantasy with slight romance

I enjoyed reading this fantasy, and eventually the whole series. Actually, I read and listened, alternatively. To me, Nicholson's narration sounded a bit fuzzy at times, not always crisp enough to easily distinguish words.

3rd person POV (my favorite for fiction) set in a medieval world called Pandemia. Plot involves a variety of races of humans/humanoids: humans, elves, goblins, dwarves, djinn, imps, pixies, faeries, trolls, mermen, gnomes, etc.

Magic centers around words of power: 1 word makes a genius, 2 words makes an adept, 3 words makes a mage, 4 words makes a sorcerer, etc. Words are highly coveted and guarded. There are ways to get words and ways to share words. It's not clear where the words come from, but Rap speculates on the subject.

So, Duncan's magical fantasy series begins here, with a stable boy, a princess, magical words, politics, and several mysteries. There is tension between the four ruling warlocks and between the Imps (organized, socially savvy, elegant) and the Jotun / Jotnar (rough seafaring Viking types from Nordland). Goblins also play a big role in this series, as do the Djinn from Zark (much like Arabia, stereotyped).

No sex or swearing, but it does get grisly at times, especially in goblin land. It's also fairly heartwarming at times, and occasionally just mildly amusing. A thread of romance runs through it -- a stableboy yearning for a princess.

I enjoyed the plot. Not crazy about the princess, but I'm rooting for Rap, the stableboy who grew up by the end of this first book. Hooray also for Fleabag the wolf. I am also strangely attached to Little Chicken, the goblin.

Good map in the book -- even higher resolution map at the author's website.

Quibble: Duncan writes very well, but IMO, he uses too much anachronistic language in this series which yanks me out of the medieval setting.

Key Characters to make listening easier:

Holindarn, King of Krasnegar, his sister Aunt Kadolin (Kade), his daughter Princess Inos (Inosolin), Rap (Raparakagozi), factotum Foronod (a Jotnar / Jotun), stable-master hostler Hononin, Guard Master Thosolin, psychotic killer Thane Kalkor of Gark (a Jotnar pirate raider from Nordland), Duke Angliki in Kinvale, duchess Ekki, chaplain Mother Unonini, Djinn sorcerer Rasha aq'Inim Sultana of Arakkaran, Imperor Emshandar, Yggingi Pronconsul in Pondague, Little Chicken goblin from Raven Clan.

There is also a charismatic imp named Andor, Jalon the half-elf minstrel, Darad the Jotun ogre, Dr Sagorn the old scholarly Jotun, and Thinal the thief, an imp.

The Four Warlocks: Bright Water goblin sorceress of the North, Lith'rian elf sorcerer of the South, Olybino imp of the East, and Zinixo dwarf of West.

I read this series and the follow-up series "A Handful of Men" which also features Rap as hero.

3 people found this helpful

Last paragraph of the story is missing

What made the experience of listening to Magic Casement the most enjoyable?

I enjoyed the book and I'm looking forward to listening to the second, however - This recording is missing the last paragrah of the story. The way it ended seemed a little off so I checked an online version of the full bood and there is a very important part missing.

7 people found this helpful

This is how not to end a novel

Cliff-hangers can be frustrating. I felt that this book ended just before a climax and ended awkwardly.

The story is interesting, and hooks you from the beginning. If I didn't have the next book in my library, I would have gone bonkers. I decided to give the next book in the series a chance to see if it moves the story along better, and ends on a better note. That will decide the series for me.

I don't know that I will recommend this book - just be aware that if you decide to read this book, you will definitely not be satisfied with the ending unless you have the next book handy - reader beware!

2 people found this helpful

Supposed to be a classic... it just didn't grab me

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

I'm not really sure what it was about this book - it's been recommended to me by several people, but after reading through about half of it, it just dragged on and on without anything of substance ever happening that warranted enough interest for me to keep reading.

I might come back to this one, but there just didn't seem to be an engaging plotline; In several hours of listening, nothing happens besides following an adolescent girl through an exceedingly boring court life, listening to her whine about how boring it is, and then following the plot line of an unremarkable stable boy that was gaining magical powers (although they very well may be the more dull magical powers ever to grace the written page).

What do you think your next listen will be?

Something more modern...

What do you think the narrator could have done better?

The narrator was fine, really. No complaints there.

If you could play editor, what scene or scenes would you have cut from Magic Casement?

The entire first half of the book.

Any additional comments?

Nope. This isn't bad writing, it just wasn't my preference. Perhaps I'm just desensitized by more modern fantasy writing that includes more structure, world building, and conflict.

7 people found this helpful

A very enjoyable audiobook.

I picked this up based on the the fact that I pride myself on having read, or at least having been familiar with, most of the fantasy series that people consider “classics” or important... Call me a nerdy snob if you must.

That said, until I came across a book in another series by Dave Duncan in the new releases section I had never heard of him or his books. Upon further investigation I realized that there’s a hole in my snobby-nerd, fantasy knowledge. From my research I picked this book to start my acquaintance with Duncan’s work.

I have to say that I’m glad that I took a chance with this audiobook/series. The writing is professional, well considered and deep. The narration is also excellent. In fact, until the last third of the book, I was wholly enchanted. Unfortunately, Duncan made the same mistake that many authors make and decided to have the plot hinge on one of the characters being immensely dense as well as on miscommunication between characters.

This kind of writing ploy, in my opinion, is the worst tendency of authors who get lazy and stop bothering to make sure that the characters’ motivations and intelligence match their actions. Instead of coming up with novel ideas to create real tension that moves the plot, they lazily generate tension that feels cheap, frustrating, and artificial.

It was doubly annoying because up to that point this was a five star book. Still though, it didn’t manage to ruin the whole audiobook. It just knocked some of the shine off of it. So Duncan gets 4 stars instead of five from this snobby, fantasy nerd.

It’s worth the credit, and I will pick up the next book... but with a little less enthusiasm than I might have if the author hadn’t offended my delicate sensibilities.

4 people found this helpful

Love the story, but the production values...

Loved the book when I first read it. Great world, interesting development.

But the sibilance in every sentence with an 's'!!! Dropped me right out of the story a number of times. The rest of the books appear to be from the same team, so I'll tough it out eventually, but I'll work through most of my library first!

1 person found this helpful