Interesting book but irritating listen

The main narrator makes this book an interesting listen but it's let down by the other voices who imitate members of the band and also people who had been interviewed by the author.



The imitated American accents are an insult to the ear and sound like chalk on a blackboard.



Also, the author has tried to cleverly shoehorn in Queen song titles into sentences but it is also an irritant



On the whole , it's full of interesting trivia but you're better off reading the book rather than listening to it.

13 people found this helpful

Dreadful. Don't buy.

I'm a big fan of biographies and auto-biographies, my favourites being those of musicians particularly. I've read and listened to many (some of which are awfully good and very insightful) and I purchased this (along side a couple of others) before I went on holiday recently. I have to say that this was a huge disappointment to me.

Lesley-Ann Jones is a hack journalist who writes (or has written) for the Daily Mail, Mail on Sunday and the Mail's Sunday supplement magazine. This book sounds basically like a stitched together series of journalistic quotes and sections that have been written over the years (possibly by many writers) and then regurgitated by this author. The structure of the book is very much quote to quote from celebs and contemporaries and it lurches a bit between them to make them fit. The quotes are badly stitched together.

The book is stuffed full of filler - digressions into frankly irrelevant characters, or pieces of rock trivia that serve no purpose and offer no insight into the supposed subject of the book.

If in doubt Jones will fall back on information about the band generally, or what the other band members were doing, but it rarely offers any genuine insight into their relationships.

The overall impression of the piece is quite superficial and glossy. It reiterates rumours and paddles in the urban myths about the band quite a lot. This book didn't give me anything at all that I had seen or heard elsewhere on TV etc.

I appreciate that Freddie Mercury was known to be a secretive guy who preserved his private life and his public/private boundary - and it does come across that Jones did try to track people down to gain some insight into the man - but she failed utterly.

The product is very much like one of those cringeworthy 'E' documentaries that leaps and skims forward months at a time. The quotes are performed by actors who impersonate the source of the quote. There is an actor voicing Freddie Mercury where his quotes have been used. The quality is poor. It doesn't work at all.

It never captured the excitement of the man or the band and it didn't compel me to continue.

When promised 'the definitive biography' I expected a whole lot more than I was delivered. I really wouldn't spend money or a credit on this title.

11 people found this helpful

Workman like

Somewhat mechanical. Would have been better reading it. The impressionists are absolutely atrocious and enormously irritating; trying to do a performance. The main narrator isn’t too bad but somewhat breathless - think the opening narration of Quantum Leap.

It got more and more annoying as it progressed. I stuck with it but I’m not sure it was worth it.

6 people found this helpful

Not enough about Freddie

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

I would if the person was more interested in the music and groups of the time.

What was the most interesting aspect of this story? The least interesting?

Freddie's childhood was the most interesting.
I got bored with the details of all the music and other bands.

How did the narrator detract from the book?

I did not like the voices used especially that of "Freddie's mother" she sounded as if she was permanently crying and it was irritating and whiny.

Was Freddie Mercury: The Definitive Biography worth the listening time?

Yes.

5 people found this helpful

Very tabloid newspaper

I don’t like the authors sensationalist way of writing! As a fan of Queen and Freddy Mercury I am disappointed in the book ! The writing was more like a report from a tabloid newspaper.

1 person found this helpful

God save our queen.

Would definitely recommend this, Freddie came across exactly as I thought. A complex character Great to hear about the rock and roll parties.
Thank you Queen for the many years of music, and many more to come.

Terrible reader spoils the book

I love queen & their story is so interesting & true rock history so was really excited to listen to this book, however an hour in I couldn't take the voice of the reader a second more, in fact it bothered me so much I returned the book. I didn't listen to a trailer, I will from now on!

Loved it

Just wish the film and the book would some how play the same song……still worth reading

Terrible narration

Don’t buy! Terrible narration by the main narrator and others. Buy the actual book and read it instead.

Disappointing

Disappointing drivel. Terrible narrator, monotone at best. Only the relevant facts made me listen to the end. Avoid