Incredibly Odd Reading

Here's why it's an incredibly odd reading: James Doohan, who has proven himself an exceptional narrator across a wide catalog of audiobooks, does a really terrible job with this story. Had he not in fact starred on the actual episode, his inability to render any of the characters with an appreciable level of authenticity could be overlooked. But if you're a fan of the series, here's the challenge: see how long can you endure listening to Data's lines delivered as though he were a confused Dalek. I lasted just a few minutes before logging on to see if there's any way I can get back the very few dollars I spent on this book.

4 people found this helpful

for STOS fans

This episode of STNG is highly appealing... possibly only to we die-hard STOS fans. But if you loved the original series, you will love the episode. This novelization did not have much additional content, as I was led to believe. Mostly it had some things which were different from the episode, and frankly not as good as in the episode. It was nice to listen to James Doohan's voice, my his sweet soul rest in peace, but "all in all" I did not really enjoy this audiobook. I recommend rewatching the TV episode, instead.

1 person found this helpful

A Great Novel Featuring Scotty

I loved it.

It is a great novel featuring the Legendary Scotty in his return to the 24th Century.

A great retelling.

A damn fine tale! The fact that two of Starfleet's finest narrated it is even better.

fun

it was fun to listen to . and I remember listening to this year's ago

a great book, painful to listen to

I love Doohan. but his reading is painful. he did a scene with Spiner. did he forget 5hat data talks normally?

A terrible reading of a great story

I was really surprised almost immediately as the story began. I was expecting it to be brilliant considering the narrators that were enlisted. I understand the narrators will never be the characters from the series and usually have no problem visualizing the store as it takes place. I read and listen to many Star Trek novels. However, the interpretation of the characters in this story was so poorly done, that I could not get engaged in the story. Data was read as though he were a computer or robot with a monotone voice. Worf sounded like a homeless ferengi with a terrible hangover. I just could not get into the story with the characters being portrayed the way they were.

Scotty and Relics

It was amazing to hear James Doohan narrative of this Star Trek The Next Generation episode. A must have.

excellent

Listening to James Doohan's voice is hypnotic and really made me feel in the scene. Looking forward for more audiobooks like this one.

Story as expected

The story was as expected however the performance did not match the kind of inflection and nuance that was found in the original episode.